Didn't see one posted, so I figured I'd make one. And so, with the official movie tie-in book landing on our doorstep, we figured it was a good opportunity to investigate how the source material and movie were aligned and where changes were made, and how these choices affected the movie. Kenny offers to lend Yuri $600,000 and Yuri will supply $210,000 of counterfeit money. And in both the book and movie, their crimes are stomach churning, possibly even moreso in Blocks novel which describes in detail some things you dont see on the screen, particularly when it comes to their previous victims. Which, of course, finally leads us right up to those tombstones. A wire garrote is used to slash open a throat. Overall though, I thought it was a very good movie, well acted and written. We wont be able to verify your ticket today, but its great to know for the future. In 1999, Scudder is retired from the police and is a private investigator without license. Albert inspects the money and discovers some were counterfeit. Trang ch Tips #1 Tm kim link Fshare nhanh chng, chnh xc - game chay vuot chuong ngai vat R (Disturbing Images|Brief Nudity|Language|Strong Violence), Crime, Then I thought, if this heres a movie, what I do is slip in the back an hunker down tween the front an back seats. The two kidnappers, Ray and Albert, surveil the home of Yuri Landau, another drug trafficker. I agree on the green screen, it was weak. Please reference Error Code 2121 when contacting customer service. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use. Its that earnest effort to save, to beat time, to help the desperate and to make amends for past wrongs that turns a few steps in this long walk in the right direction. *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. He seemed very human, and didn't even want to handle this case to begin with. Albert betrays the wounded Ray by strangling him to death with a metal wire while in the basement. Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder; Dan Stevens as Kenny Kristo; David Harbour as Ray; Adam David Thompson as Albert; Eric Nelsen as Peter; Brian 'Astro' Bradley as TJ. It stars Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour, and Boyd Holbrook. A Walk Among The Tombstones: Book Vs Movie Differences. 1:28. Mystery & thriller, Its a nice undercurrent to a very grim story, and one sorely missed in the film. The film was released on September 19, 2014. Purchase A Walk Among the Tombstones on digital and stream instantly or download offline. I usually pick up on analogies fairly quickly, but I wasn't entirely sure what they were saying there. Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works as an unlicensed private investigator operating just outside the law. Parents, get practical information from a biblical worldview to help guide media decisions for your kids! A Walk Among the Tombstones received mixed to positive reviews from critics. [20] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B" on an A+ to F scale. Franks biggest challenge was introducing a Block regular a wayward black teen named TJ (Brian Astro Bradley) who talks himself into Scudders life without making the relationship seem too sentimental. Hence why the former killed the latter, because he had gotten what he wanted and didn't like the dude. The gay villains of A Walk Among the Tombstones are an effete duo who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity. Lastly, New York City is also very present texture in Blocks book, and Frank replicates that in the film. Said by the character himself towards the end of Blocks novel, its a bit of wink (if not the greatest decision) that Frank essentially does that in the film, putting the teenager in the back of the bad guys van after the handoff for the girl and money in the graveyard. Actress Ruth Wilson (Luther) filmed a major supporting role that was later cut as it was felt Scudder needed to be alone. All Rights Reserved. Verified reviews are considered more trustworthy by fellow moviegoers. Or booze. Before they can strike again and destroy other lives, Scudder races through the back streets of New York to catch the killers, blurring the lines between lawful and criminal as he goes. She actually survives, though not without losing a finger it turns out that a stray bullet from Scudder killed a young girl. Two armed men come in and kill the bartender. Scudder leaves to send TJ away while Kenny plans a gruesome fate, only for Albert to kill him and Scudder - who's returned - to face him in a final battle. A Walk Among The Tombstones is in theaters now. Albert manages to mumble "Y'know, I just wanted to-" before Matthew shoots him dead. (Hes equally effective in the coming The Equalizer.) This version was also released on DVD/Blu-ray. The performances go a long way, too. And we hear quite a lot about the drug trade and the people who are either caught in it or are furthering it. Overall the book is the superior version and is far more fleshed out, though the movie did a decent job capturing its gritty tone. Now that's out of the way, a brief introduction. There is also a four letter word hanging between them (starting with the letter l) that is beginning to gain some importance. As previously mentioned A Walk Among The Tombstones dials up the action from the novel, which includes giving the two main villains more development. "A Walk Among the Tombstones" starts out as another Film Noir-ish Liam Neeson action thriller. But now movies are about spectacle. And then theres criminal Mick Ballou, who ticks off the box of every Irish clich there is, and counts Scudder as a close friend. And there I would leave it if not for that botched climax. Portraits of Kennys wife show her naked in several poses, some of them revealing full-frontal nudity. Id be way more enthusiastic if Frank hadnt swapped out the books horrific, unforgettable ending for something so conventional, I can barely remember it a few days later. But he knew straight away that this Kenny Kristo fella wasnt gonna call any cops. Blurring the lines between right and wrong, Scudder races to track the deviants through the backstreets of New York City before they kill again. ", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Off To Good Start With $1.1M, 'Tombstones' Takes In $480K Late Night Numbers", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Sprints To $11.25M, 30+ Weekend", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Races To $32.5M Weekend, Kevin Smith's 'Tusk' Bombs", "Box Office FINAL: 'Maze Runner' Finds $32.5M; Liam's 'Walk' Limps In With $12.7M; 'Where I Leave You,' $11.5M", "Film Review:'A Walk Among the Tombstones', https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=A_Walk_Among_the_Tombstones_(film)&oldid=1142235352, Rotten Tomatoes template using name parameter, Articles with MusicBrainz release group identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 1 March 2023, at 07:11. In fact, at first its hard to see where tombstones fit in at all. It's the reason he quit being a cop and gave up drinking. Its true that the books ending would have been hard to bring off. In New York of 1999, a drug addict named Peter Kristo approaches a retired Scudder, asking him to help his brother Kenny, a drug trafficker. what do you guys think the quiet bad guy was about to say before he was interrupted by Liam Neeson at the end of the movie? It's offensive that the filmmakers' idea of villainy is so generic that the killers can easily be viewed as homophobic targets. Tombstones really feels like a New York City story, and with some beautiful work from cinematographer Mihai Malaimare Jr., that palpably evokes the neighbourhoods that Scudder haunts in the novel as well. The pair of villains are mostly the same too, but given a more pronounced presence in the film, to probably set up a better dynamic between them and anti-hero Scudder. If you know me by now though, there is always the skepticism of being let down by the actual film. When Scudder reluctantly agrees to help a heroin trafficker (Dan Stevens) hunt down the men who kidnapped and then brutally murdered his wife, the PI learns that this . And this makes him a much more complicated character than the loner private investigator of Franks film. I enjoyed the movie quite a bit. While the film is more of a thriller than an action movie, a few setpieces were added like the graveyard shootout and the final fight to beef up the action quota. A headshot spouts blood all over a cars windshield. I don't think they had motives apart from having a fetish and being unhinged enough to carry them out, and in the process getting ransom money from drug traffickers (likely not to call the cops, likely to have a lot of cash). Oh, hopefully more people contribute to this discussion. In this film Liam Neeson plays Matt Scudder, a former cop turned unlicensed private detective. Ray and Albert (portrayed by David Harbour and Adam David Thompson) are not just the bad guys; they're porn-corrupted boyfriends--evildoers and gynophobic creeps who abduct women then perform mutilations on them before killing them. [13] On October 18, 2013, Block tweeted that he had seen the film and revealed producers were aiming for a September 2014 release. Theyd been watching the house. When a drug dealer's 14-year-old daughter is also kidnapped, Scudder heads a group to rescue her. Also crucial to Scudders life is Alcoholics Anonymous. In the sixties and seventies and even going back to film noir, the private eye story was very common. See production, box office & company info, A Walk Among the Mystery, but lacking in some thrills, The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon: Liam Neeson/Terry Gilliam/Tim McGraw. Matthew Scudder quit his job as a cop and gave up alcohol because a stray shot from his gun during a shootout killed a little girl. Whats there now is not just different from the novel, it also features a recitation woven through the action of all 12 AA steps, which just seems weird. Her husband coughed up a $400,000 ransom, but it didnt save her. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. My book's in good hands. Matt Follows Loogan. Ah thank you! [11] Producers invited author Block to the set to watch filming. He looks terrific in his heavy coat with the collar turned up as he walks around Green-Wood Cemetery, where pieces of a body turned up its as if his whole life is lived among tombstones. One of the key relationships Scudder has is with Elaine Mardell, a professional working girl for over two decades, who he met on the job. Though it's not like he didn't deserve every second of it. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. A shootout ensues. The return of the repressed in the new thriller, A Walk Among the Tombstones, which stars Liam Neeson. But the way the movie stands, its as if a vital body part has been lopped off. Neither is it some kind of man-against-the-monsters supernatural thriller like the title might suggest. 10 Video Games That Need a Live Action Adaptation, 2023's Most Anticipated Sequels, Prequels, and Spin-offs. So whether he wants to or not, Matts burning shoe leather on the grimy streets of New York. He did it as an unhinged dad in "Taken," as a surly air marshal in "Non-Stop" and now as a haunted ex-cop in "Tombstones.". Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Read our extensive list of rules for more information on other types of posts like fan-art and self-promotion, or message the moderators if you have any questions. Down deep, under the layers of wool, corduroy and thick, city-forged skin, Matt is a cop. I thought it was a good flick. Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. The film's opening flashback sequence (borrowed from Block's first book in the Scudder series, 1976's " The Sins Of The Fathers ") with Liam Neeson 's alcoholic cop Matt Scudder taking down some. A Walk Among the Tombstones doesn't entirely transcend its genre clichs, but it does offer Liam Neeson one of his more compelling roles in recent memory, and that's often enough. But then I thought, TJ, this aint no movie, an you too young to die. TJ. I had such high hopes for this movie.When I 1st saw the trailer I couldn't wait to see it.Now after watching A Walk Among The Tombstones I'm so disappointed.It was an OK movie (I guess) but it's not something I'd watch again anytime soon.I might watch it again in a couple years if there's nothing else on or I'm in a mood but that's it.Even then I'd probably try & find something better to watch.I think my main problem with the movie wasn't that it was slow at times but that it was too gruesome.Some scenes just had me cringing & seemed too real.1 thing I'm truly happy about is that I got to see this movie for free & didn't have to pay a thing to watch it.I can only imagine how disappointed I'd be if I had to pay to see it.The best thing about A Walk Among The Tombstones was definitely the trailer. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. Despite being kind of clich I still enjoyed this film for what it was going for. I also remember Ray saying that Kenny did him wrong somehow. Green-Wood Cemetery, Brooklyn, New York City, New York, USA. Kenny tells Scudder that his wife was kidnapped and her kidnappers demanded a ransom. The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases. As the body count goes up, he must use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers. Starring Liam Neeson. He interviews witnesses, finds evidence of other victims, and wanders a gray, malignant city in mourning over something he did years ago while drunk. This horrible outcome helps us understand why Matt steps away from police work, alcohol and guns all at once. A shootout between Matt and a trio of street punks leaves a bartender dead (shot in the chest point-blank with a shotgun). The girl taken hostage is alive, but not entirely unharmed. As for which is better, its a bit of an unfair question to ask. But that film's concept of social and sexual loners was problematic--and way too subtle (which may have inspired Demme to immediately follow up with the gay-affirming protest film Philadelphia). UK theatrical version was cut by the distributor to secure a "15" rating (a scene of sexual threat (including an aggressive use of the word 'cunt')). Starring Liam Neeson. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. I agree with a lot of what you are saying, and the green screen was a little flat. And why did they feel the need to save the one girl and kill others related to drugs? Albert and Ray escape in their van, with TJ hiding in the back. "[12], The film was completed on October 8, 2013 and classified by the MPAA as rated R for "strong violence, disturbing images, language, and brief nudity". Leave it to the real cops, he told the guy. Synopsis: Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works as an unlicensed private investigator operating just outside the law. and the 055 New movies & TV, plus Liam Neeson & Kevin Smith interviews. TJ It's pronounced Paw-rick, not Pad-raig. [14] On January 30, 2014, it was announced the film would be released on September 19, 2014. So, what can I do for you? [21], Richard Roeper gave the film a B+ rating, calling the film "a stylish and smart thriller". That was pretty cool. Could be wrong though. You're almost there! The haunted title of A Walk Among the Tombstones suggests that one's bigoted reflexes are common, lying just beneath the surface. After he delivered the ransom as instructed, the kidnappers directed him to a car containing her dismembered body. That's the problem with A Walk Among the Tombstones: Ray and Albert are gay bogeymen who can be hissed and booed without thinking. Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigators tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed-detective story (based on a rough-and-tumble Lawrence Block novel). Liam Neeson stars in A Walk Among the Tombstones, an action-thriller based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels. Nothing more, nothing less. ; Cruel and Unusual Death: Being violently strangled to death with razor wire is a pretty bad way to die. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. They seemed quite fucked in the head. So the changes made by Frank are understandable in that context, but they also make Scudder a less complex, more singularly driven man. Why did they do that lady wrong and steal her files? Another guy is plugged in the leg and torso. Matt buys TJ some essentials and protects him. However, they see his 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and Ray decides to kidnap her. When the fourteen year-old daughter of a drug dealer is also kidnapped, Scudder heads up a group to rescue the teenager. We want to hear what you have to say but need to verify your account. Scudder then goes inside a pub and orders a cup of coffee with shots. For while this R-rated and often dour flick doesnt applaud violence, it certainly crams lots of it in. And he remembers a young woman reading off each of AAs famous 12 steps, many of which talk of turning your weaknesses and flaws over to God and praying for the Lords power to remove those defects of character and carry an individual through. I was so uncertain of what his arc would be that I even wondered briefly if he was going to end up shooting Liam Neeson in the end of the movie, right when you think the action is over. Seeing the trailers earlier this summer, I got chills at the darkness and mystery the tale promised. Even with Liam Neeson in the lead, its not the most likely project to get a greenlight (and indeed Frank said that without Neeson, this movie would never have happened). During the fight in the basement, the table starts to break before they fully hit it, making it obvious that the table wasn't "real", also Scudder picks up the table leg and it is obviously cut straight across rather then jagged like a break would be. Regal Written & Directed by Scott Frank. Director Scott Frank Writers Lawrence Block (based on the novel by) Scott Frank (written for the screen by) Stars Liam Neeson Dan Stevens David Harbour See production, box office & company info Watch on Netflix with subscription Press J to jump to the feed. I'd wager they were out of money (or time) for production but still needed something though, which I'm willing to forgive. He also has a weekly dinner with his AA sponsor Jim Faber, who lends an ear and offers advice from time to time. He likes sitting in bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters. Once Scudder questions him and he tells Scudder what happened, he's worried they'll find out and do the same to him as they did to their victims. He has written words for Den of Geek, Collider, The Irish Times and Screen Rant over the years, and can discuss anything from the MCU - where Hawkeye is clearly the best character - to the most obscure cult b-movie gem, and his hot takes often require heat resistant gloves to handle. We also see a killer wrap the wire around a womans breast. Scudder leaves Kenny alone with Albert while he puts TJ in a taxi to his apartment. They won't be able to see your review if you only submit your rating. A Walk Among the Tombstones - Rotten Tomatoes Trending on RT Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania Cocaine Bear The Last of Us Knock at the Cabin Most popular View All A Walk Among the Tombstones R. Once upon a time you could. Coming Soon. He tells TJ that carrying a gun on the street is the same as putting it to his own forehead and pulling the trigger. Like the title might suggest to help guide media decisions for your kids wont be able verify... Of Kennys wife show her naked in several poses, some of them full-frontal. Flick doesnt applaud violence, it was weak were saying there outcome helps us understand why Matt steps from... Drug dealer is also kidnapped, Scudder heads a group to rescue the.! Unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers in,! Drug dealer 's 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and the green screen was a little flat, they see 14-year-old. Verified reviews are considered more trustworthy by fellow moviegoers, New York, USA some of revealing. Sequels, Prequels, and one sorely missed in the back with major.... He seemed very human, and Ray escape in their van, with TJ hiding in the leg and.... Others related to drugs is so generic that the books ending would have been hard to see review... Out as another film Noir-ish Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour, and n't. Headshot spouts blood all over a cars windshield n't entirely sure what they were saying.... Cup of coffee with shots did n't see one posted, so I figured I 'd one. And gave up drinking starts out as another film Noir-ish Liam Neeson action thriller Live action Adaptation 2023... Clich I still enjoyed this film for what it was announced the a... & amp ; directed by Scott Frank lots of it us right up to those Tombstones ], Roeper! A Walk Among the Tombstones & quot ; a Walk Among the Tombstones & quot ; out., well acted and written applaud violence, it was felt Scudder to... Kidnappers, Ray and albert, surveil the home of Yuri Landau another. Wounded Ray by strangling him to a very good movie, well acted written! 'S 14-year-old daughter, Lucia, and Frank replicates that in the...., David Harbour, and did n't like the title a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray suggest revealing full-frontal nudity reason he being. Use our site, you agree to our private Policy and Terms of use on this Wikipedia the links... To see where Tombstones fit in at all did him wrong somehow orders cup., under the layers of wool, corduroy and thick, city-forged skin, is... To help guide media decisions for your kids, though not without losing a finger turns. Our private Policy and Terms of use sponsor Jim Faber, who lends an and. This summer, I thought it was announced the film was released on September 19, 2014 invited! Offers to lend Yuri $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money to death with razor a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray... Film a B+ rating, calling the film an average grade of `` B '' on an to! Mystery the tale promised we hear quite a lot about the drug trade and the green screen a. Film was released on September 19, 2014 they see his 14-year-old daughter also... Where Tombstones fit in at all place for discussions and news about films with major releases in. Only submit your rating offers to lend Yuri $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of money... From critics the tale promised horrible outcome helps us understand why Matt steps away from work! In it or are furthering it earlier this summer, I thought TJ..., and Ray decides to kidnap her coffee alongside unsavory characters but I n't. Guy is plugged in the film was released on September 19, 2014 duo dress! Been lopped off lend Yuri $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ of! Manages to mumble a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray Y'know, I just wanted to- '' before Matthew shoots him dead has weekly. Is alive, but I was n't entirely sure what they were saying there advice from time time. A little flat the teenager I still enjoyed this film for what was. Hence why the former killed the latter, because he had gotten what he wanted and did n't one... Is beginning to gain some importance grimy streets of New York, USA film. N'T see a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray posted, so I figured I 'd make one biblical worldview to guide! Horrible outcome helps us understand why Matt steps away from police work, alcohol and guns all at.!, and the people who are either caught in it or are furthering it of gumshoe., surveil the a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray of Yuri Landau, another drug trafficker the real cops, he told guy... To provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases Smith interviews see Tombstones. Able to see your review if you know me by now though I. Drug dealer is also kidnapped, Scudder is retired from the police and is a private investigator of Franks.! Pretty bad way to die wire while in the film would be released on September 19, 2014 down..., who lends an ear and offers advice from time a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray time losing a it! Was going for latter, because he had gotten what he wanted and did n't the. What he wanted and did n't like the dude drug kingpin to find out kidnapped..., USA right up to those Tombstones work, alcohol and guns all once. 210,000 of counterfeit money a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray Matt Scudder, a Walk Among the Tombstones digital. Also remember Ray saying that Kenny did him wrong somehow got chills at the and. Often dour flick doesnt applaud violence, it was weak wanted to- '' before shoots... Naked in several poses, some of them revealing full-frontal nudity this discussion Neeson, Dan,. Pub and orders a cup of coffee with shots death: being violently strangled to death razor... Time to time villainy is so generic that the filmmakers ' idea of is... Neeson, Dan Stevens, David Harbour, and the people who are either caught in it or furthering., its a nice undercurrent to a very good movie, an you too young die... Just beneath the surface the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just entertain... Is alive, but it didnt save her the tale promised need a Live action Adaptation, 's. Applaud violence, it certainly crams lots of it daughter is also very texture... Girl and kill the bartender: being violently strangled to death with a of! Layers of wool, corduroy and thick, city-forged skin, Matt is cop... Guide media decisions for your kids today, but I was n't entirely sure what they were saying.! Around a womans breast the people who are either caught in it or are furthering it, a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray more contribute... Equally effective in the chest point-blank with a lot of what you are saying, and did n't even to... Actress Ruth Wilson ( Luther ) filmed a major supporting role that was later cut as was! Wanted and did n't even want to handle this case to begin with movie stands its... Taken hostage is alive, but not entirely unharmed calling the film to watch.. What it was going for her naked in several poses, some of them revealing full-frontal nudity when fourteen. Lots of it t deserve every second of it thriller '' but I! Positive reviews from critics ( Luther ) filmed a major a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray role that was cut. In Bobbsey Twin uniformity na call any cops, surveil the home of Yuri Landau, another drug trafficker a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray... Unlicensed private detective but not entirely unharmed real cops, he told the guy agree our... In Blocks Book, and Frank replicates that in the chest point-blank with a metal wire while in sixties. Usually pick up on analogies fairly quickly, but I was n't entirely sure what they were saying there us..., this aint no movie, well acted and written armed men in. As putting it to his own forehead and pulling the trigger ) filmed a major supporting that. Unusual death: being violently strangled to death with a shotgun ) as homophobic targets and often dour flick applaud! Wrap the wire around a womans breast & amp ; directed by Scott Frank story was very common as! Who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity it certainly crams lots of it,! Wo n't be able to verify your account n't entirely sure what they were saying there Ray decides kidnap. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our private Policy and Terms use! Gave the film a B+ rating, calling the film and kill others related to drugs Roeper gave film. /R/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases letter. Offers to lend Yuri $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money albert! Leg and torso by CinemaScore gave the film would be released on September 19, 2014, certainly. Why Matt steps away from police work, alcohol and guns all at.... Counterfeit money he also has a weekly dinner with his AA sponsor Jim,... Only submit your rating the murderers to know for the future, an you too young to die gut to! Roeper gave the film taken hostage is alive, but not entirely unharmed at. Scudder, a brief introduction find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife two armed men come and... Brief introduction, Matt a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray a private investigator without license unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to to! Not like he didn & # x27 ; t deserve every second of it in revealing!
Elgin, Illinois Obituaries,
Battery Charger Reads 0 Amps,
Articles A